Greg Everett:
Its very very annoying to hear this horseshit that olympic lifts and their variations only "express" strength, and I have yet to see it said by anyone who actually has the experience under the bar with these lifts themselves say such a dumb ass thing. Deadlifts VERY OFTEN will go up SUBSTANTIALLY, WITHOUT DEADLIFTING, from doing power cleans from the floor. Power cleans WONT go up linearly, from getting stronger in the deadlift. This is one reason using power cleans from the floor is a great option for team sport athletes, it saves the cns from the burn out of heavy deadlifting, gives a MUCH better carryover to jumps/sprints/power, and yet it still will improve the actual deadlift itself in most cases assuming the athlete can adequately perform the lift.
I think no one would seriously doubt the benefits of the olympic lifts for every strength and power athlete. However, if the olympic lifts are actually sufficient and also efficient in making athletes stronger, why does every weightlifter on the planet feel the need to squat and/or front squat so often then? It certainly is not only because of variety.
I never said that olympic lifts were the only lifts needed. I said Im tired of hearing that they "demonstrate" strength, and dont make people stronger. Olympic lifters do the SQUAT CLEAN and SQUAT SNATCH, so the squat is a very integral factor in whether or not they make the lift. Im not talking about olympic lifters anyway, Im sick of seeing posts about how "olympic lifts only "demonstrate" strength".
The argument whether deadlift increases drive powerclean increases or vice versa is completely artificial IMO. It's neither nor. Serious training will lead to adaptations from the organism and those adaptations apply to similar tasks as well. So there are obviously variables in play that mediate the connection and this will probably work in both directions to an extend.
Im telling you that increases in powercleans, FROM THE FLOOR, increase the deadlift IN MOST athletes in my experience, im not asking anybody, because ive seen it happen for 15 years. Without deadlifting, assuming they can powerclean correctly, their deadlifts go up, WITHOUT DEADLIFTING. Would the deadlift go up MORE with more deadlifting? possibly and probable, but deadlifting without cleaning does not work the same way in my experience for the clean.
Now, for an olympic lifter there is no need to increase his deadlift unless this increase has carryover to competition lifts. And this is the actual debate and point of disagreement from my perception of it.
Im not talking about Mark Rippetoes insane argument with every olympic weightlifting coach on the planet, Im talking about the kids repeating this shit all over every s and c forum on the internet, with a tone of "why should we even do power cleans or power snatches when all they do is "display" strength. You want to know what helps olympic weightlifters? ask glenn pendlay, listen to every word he says and disregard anything anyone else says about it.
cleans and snatches and all their variations make people strong, on the field, on the court, and stronger in general just like other lifts but at a more sport specific speed. Its progressive overload against increasing resistance. You dont have to do them, just like you dont have to do any lift, but saying they dont make people strong is insane.