166
Strength, Power, Reactivity, & Speed Discussion / Re: Utilization of Strength
« on: August 30, 2011, 09:19:36 pm »What about BSS vs Squat for one leg jumpers? You can say BSS is more specific, but uses less total weight. However, is the total weight important? Or is what important the amount of load per leg?
For example:
What would be more difficult (let's pretend the guy doing this has no issues with balancing):
5 reps with 80 kg on the BSS
OR
5 reps with 160 kg on the squat.
How do you define "difficult"? How do you define the training effect that happens after doing this ^^^? What is more important - the amount of tension that occurs in the leg in the BSS or the amount of overall "body" tension that occurs during the squat? What if you use say 130 kg on the squat? What then? Can you say that a BSS makes you aware and able to concentrate all your might (nervous energy if you will) on one limb better than a squat would do?
Obviously the thing is, in training, consistency. That's what's important. But we talk about stuff like this because we (at least I do) like the challenge of deciphering all these "enigmas" (for some, others have a strong belief in one method or another).
I think Pavel Tsatsouline said that what's most important is the amount of tension in a muscle more than anything, it doesn't matter through what methods - traditional, iso, eccentric, whatever.
The best argument I've read on this topic is that bilateral lifts simply produce more power than single leg lifts. So if your training goal is power related, it just makes sense to focus on increasing resistance and power production through a bilateral lift like the squat- simply because the potential to apply force is greater than with a single leg lift. You have to think that power is very specific to training itself.
Max power output is the most specific work that I focus on in the gym because I can't apply the force necessary to reach my goals yet. But single leg lifts can definitely help a lot as accessory. I have seen my single leg jump really improve after mixing in step ups and some other single leg lifts, but they weren't heavy at all. I don't see why you would want to replace squats with bss as your main lift. It would probably work a lot better if you do heavy squats first then do bss with lighter weight and move them fast. You'd get the best of both worlds.