LMAO i have a strong prejudice against olympic swimming because of the australian obsession with the 'sport' .. even worse than acole i think, cos I dont even try to be balanced about it. bolt all the way. However, i love the idea of comparing athletes .. who is the greatest of all time? Who even makes the top 5? Does Lebron make the cut?
Phelps is the greatest Olympian of all time (23 Gold medals) but Bolt is definitely a better athlete. Everyone can run, and it doesn't matter whether you are in China, Russia, Ivory Coast or the US etc. You don't need any special equipment and it doesn't require any specialized skills. It is the purest form of performance. Even if people wanted to make a counter-argument that anybody can swim I think you'd just need to look at the various sports Phelps and Bolt could excel at and you'd chose Bolt over Phelps for your football and basketball team any day of the week over Phelps. I don't really like comparing them though because they are both masters at their chosen sports.